The Stacks
True-story books, and what is disputed about them
What is disputed about famous true-story books, and what they leave out, in our own words.
Some of the best-known true stories are also the most argued over, so we keep them and say what is disputed. These are the “Worth knowing” notes from our true-story shelves, in one place.
True Crime
-
In Cold Blood
Worth knowing. Its accuracy is disputed: Capote invented or rearranged some scenes, including the closing one, and the investigators’ own files differ from parts of his account. First serialised in 1965.
-
The Executioner’s Song
Worth knowing. Written as a “non-fiction novel” with reconstructed dialogue, and centred far more on the killer than on the two men he killed.
-
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
Worth knowing. Berendt has acknowledged compressing the timeline and placing himself in scenes he did not witness.
-
The Devil in the White City
Worth knowing. Historians say the “murder castle” legend and the large victim counts often given for Holmes come from sensational newspapers of the time; his confirmed victims are far fewer. Some scenes are reconstructed.
-
Say Nothing
Worth knowing. It names living people in connection with allegations they deny, among them Gerry Adams, and draws on the contested Boston College oral-history tapes.
Serial Killers · Case Files
-
Whoever Fights Monsters
Worth knowing. Criminal profiling’s scientific basis is contested.
-
Mindhunter
Worth knowing. Criminal profiling’s scientific basis is contested, and critics say the book overstates its successes.
-
The Five
Worth knowing. Some historians of the case dispute her argument that several of the women were not working as prostitutes.
-
Lost Girls
Worth knowing. The book came out ten years before a suspect was charged in 2023, so it does not cover him or the case against him.
Unsolved Mysteries
-
Zodiac
Worth knowing. Graysmith points to a named suspect who was never charged and has since died; later DNA and handwriting comparisons did not match him.
-
The Mothman Prophecies
Worth knowing. Keel treats paranormal explanations as real possibilities; there is no evidence for them. The bridge failed because of a cracked eyebar.
-
The Monster of Florence
Worth knowing. It points to people as possible suspects who have never been charged with the murders.
-
Dead Mountain
Worth knowing. Its explanation is one of several. A Russian inquiry in 2019–20 and a 2021 scientific study favour a slab avalanche.
-
The Mysterious Case of Rudolf Diesel
Worth knowing. Brunt offers a speculative solution that has not been confirmed.
Weird History
-
Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds
Worth knowing. Historians say Mackay exaggerated several episodes, tulip mania among them.
Strange Science
-
The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat
Worth knowing. A December 2025 New Yorker report, drawing on Sacks’s own journals, said he altered or invented details in some of his case studies, including in this book.
Cults & Cons
-
Helter Skelter
Worth knowing. Written by the case’s prosecutor; the motive it sets out has been questioned since, for example in Tom O’Neill’s Chaos (2019).
-
Under the Banner of Heaven
Worth knowing. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints publicly criticised its portrayal of the mainstream church.
-
Going Clear
Worth knowing. The Church of Scientology disputes the book’s account.
-
Catch Me If You Can
Worth knowing. Largely fabricated: Alan C. Logan’s The Greatest Hoax on Earth (2020) used public records to show that most of the exploits it describes did not happen.